Moving On – Part 2 – Coming Unstuck

Once the initial sting from the incident with the Aboriginal man in Visitor Centre subsided the woman could see that the situation had its funny side. An question about glue making had led to her coming unstuck on all kinds of levels.

Beyond that wry humour though were some difficult realizations.

Googling cultural appropriation had bought up a lot of interesting articles written from an indigenous perspective. Reading them she could understand their anger.   Of course Native Americans would be disturbed by the sight of fashion models wearing traditional War Bonnets on the catwalk.  Of course Asians had the right to be offended when a pop star painted her face yellow and pretended she knew what it was like to be Asian in a predominately white country.  Of course Aboriginal people were grieving over the loss of their country and the way their culture was constantly appropriated by others.

Online she searched for a definition of cultural appropriation. Opinions varied as to what it actually was but through careful reading she came up with her own understanding  – cultural appropriation occurred when the ideas, beliefs and/or artifacts of a minority group were taken out of context and used for the material gain of others.  In other words it was a kind of theft.

One thing that bothered many indigenous people was the way their ideas and sacred objects were taught in New Age workshops by people who had no cultural connection to those ideas and objects.  Reading that the woman found herself in a very grey area – a place where some of the values and objects she cherished began to come unstuck.  Did that mean she should dispense with them and cherish only values and objects that came from her own ancestral cultural heritage?

DSCN9585

Alone in the light of the full moon she walked around the Medicine Wheel she had created in her garden. Was it wrong of to her to that?  Sure she’d originally learnt the about the Four Directions from other white women in New Age workshops.  Since creating the Wheel though she had spent time exploring the deeper significance of the ideas surrounding it.  Then there was the time-out-of-time she spent sitting and standing in the Wheel holding her own private rituals where she acknowledged her connection to the Earth and the Cosmos.  The experiential insights she had gained then about the sacred nature of all life could not be forgotten.  They had become the cornerstone of her being.

The Medicine Wheel was just one example. There were the objects she made intuitively with natural materials – feathers, sticks, leather, string and gemstones. The private things she made in ceremony and rarely showed to others. Her own version of sacred objects.

Sometimes after the making she would discover in an old book or during some random online surfing that the objects she made were similar to sacred objects used by indigenous people, particularly the Lakota Indians.  Attempting to understand herself she had come to think that maybe the desire to make these objects came to her because of past life connections with the Lakota. Alternatively her Western mind reflected on Jung’s ideas of the Universal Unconscious and Joseph Campbell’s ideas about sacred symbols and objects that endured across time, space and cultures.

totem-copy[3]

It was the making of these objects that had led her to ask about making glue in the first place. For years she had thought that it would be better to use natural glues for the making rather than the chemical stuff that gave her headaches.  All of that had been too much to try and explain to the angry Aboriginal man though. When he’d demanded to know why she had wanted to make the glue she’d stuttered out some vague response about making dream catchers.  No doubt she’d come across as a ditz.  The man  may have thought she wanted to make them to sell.  And to be honest there were times when she’d considered making more accessible objects like Dream Catchers and selling them at markets.

The desire to do anything like had utterly deserted her now though.

Looking around at the objects she had created or purchased from others she could easily see the ones that had some kind of spiritual and sacred resonance and those which were merely decorative objects.   Those she had bought from others she bundled up and gave away a charity shop.

The ones she had made herself she dismantled systematically.   As she worked she explored her ideas and intuitions surrounding them.   It came to her that were two ways of making these things – two ways of being really.

One was grounded in the material world and often the reason for making the objects was the desire for material gain or simply to make a pretty object to hang on the wall.   The other way was  intuitive and spiritual – the world where Jung’s Universal Unconscious flowed through time, space and cultures – the Sacred Space of Ceremony and Ritual.

buddhist haiku.jpg

In that space Bunjil the Aboriginal Creator Being flew in his eagle form flew alongside the Sky Dakini of the Tibetan Buddhists and the Angels of the Christianity.

In that space the sticks and stones she glued together to make wands and prayer sticks had the same significance as similar objects made in a sacred way by indigenous people.

In that space the Black Madonna of her own cultural traditions walked alongside the Lakota White Buffalo Woman and the countless other manifestations of the Earth Goddess.

In that space the feeling of connection to life that she found in the Australian bush or on a mountain top in Ireland or in the silence of  meditation was not something she appropriated from anyone.   It was free for all to connect to.   Maybe in fact it was that energy would eventually connect all who had eyes to see it, ears to hear it and a heart to feel it.

20160225_165647.jpg

 

23 thoughts on “Moving On – Part 2 – Coming Unstuck

  1. Another very moving and thought-provoking piece. I think your works of art were simply that, pieces that resonated with you and without any thought of profiting from them, I would have been reluctant to dismantle them.

    Like

  2. Well, the crucial thing is there were no profit motives involved for you, and you were revering rather than cheapening another culture. Ideas are for sharing, aren’t they, Suzanne, but some of the rest gets difficult. I enjoyed the read 🙂 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Thursday Thought – “Cultural Appropriation” or “Yindyamarra”? – Memories & Thoughts

  4. Another insightful piece, Suzanne, and it makes me wonder about many of the things I collect too. I’m not a craft person, so I haven’t made such items myself, but I do often buy items from other cultures as warm reminders of my travels.

    I found this part interesting: “Of course Native Americans would be disturbed by the sight of fashion models wearing traditional War Bonnets on the catwalk. Of course Asians had the right to be offended when a pop star painted her face yellow and pretended she knew what it was like to be Asian in a predominately white country. Of course Aboriginal people were grieving over the loss of their country and the way their culture was constantly appropriated by others.”

    I can certainly understand the grievances of native people. Especially when appropriated by white people for monetary gain.

    When I traveled and lived in Asia, I collected many Buddha images; I also sometimes collect crosses and icons; my spirituality now seems to come together as a mingling of Buddhist and Christian and natural symbols. I enjoy looking at them and appreciating their historical and spiritual roots, and they serve as reminders to practice serenity in my daily life. I remember in Myanmar, I had to go to a government office to get special permission to take two particular Buddhas out of the country (both very small images). They wanted to know if I was Buddhist, and of course I can’t really define myself as such, so I said no, although Buddhism figures into my spiritual practice. They couldn’t understand why I wanted to take them, but I didn’t want to leave without them. After all, native people had sold them to me and I’d paid good money for them because they represented peace to me, plus they connected me in many ways to the lands though which I’d traveled.

    So many good questions here, and food for thought. I don’t think I’m ready to give away or dissemble any of the items I’ve collected from my travels, though, especially ones that are spiritual in nature.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ah – the Buddha images. I kept them 🙂 For years I painted Buddhas. Like you I am not a Buddhist but love having Buddhas around me. There is probably another blog post in this but not right now. Maybe when I’ve moved.

      Liked by 1 person

I love hearing what you think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s